This content University is for students. You are viewing this as a preview; to see content suitable for your group and save your progress, Log inSign up
Skip to content

A small paradox of physics: Jumping in a moving elevator

Ask a Question
Asked Latest activity Views 82 Category Physics Discussions
1

A SMALL PARADOX OF PHYSICS: JUMPING IN A MOVING ELEVATOR

An elevator is moving vertically upwards. A person inside the elevator jumps vertically upwards from the floor of the elevator.

During the person's motion, their instantaneous velocity relative to the ground becomes zero at one point. However, the elevator continues to move upwards.

Now comes the real question:

Where is the person in the elevator at the moment their velocity relative to the ground is zero? And how can we calculate the elapsed time until they fall back to the elevator floor?

Additional question:

If the elevator's speed were to change, how would this problem change?

Purely physical thinking.

asked
Physicist_LİKOS
32 Electron

5 Reply

1
Accepted solution

Fizik_yunus, to answer your question, I would put it this way: We can explain this through Newton's 1th law, namely the law of inertia. When the elevator is stopped abruptly, the person tends to maintain their current state of motion. Therefore, even though the elevator stops, the person continues their motion in the direction of their current velocity. In other words, the stopping of the elevator does not mean the person will stop at the same time. Gravity, on the other hand, continues to change the person's motion.

answered
Physicist_LİKOS
32 Electron
1

Having an instantaneous velocity of zero relative to the ground means briefly escaping the effect of the elevator's upward motion. To know this, we need to know the elevator's speed and how fast the jump was made, of course, if we need to find a precise numerical result, or are we trying to find a formula??

History
edited
answered
admin
25 Electron
Good answer — Physicist_LİKOS Electron
1

Now, looking at the first step of the problem, let's consider the situation when the person's velocity relative to the ground is zero. If the elevator is moving at a constant speed, the person exerts an action force on the elevator floor at the moment of jumping, and the floor exerts a reaction force, momentarily causing the person to move upward faster than the elevator. Looking at the issue from this perspective, the person moved faster than the elevator, but since the elevator also continues to move, the person will be slightly below the middle region of the elevator cabin. Let our flight time at this instant be "t". If the elevator is undergoing accelerated motion—specifically, if it is accelerating—considering the elevator floor as a surface, the gravitational force acting on the person, i.e., the normal force, is increasing. Thus, the person stays in the air for the shortest time t and reaches a lower height. However, if the elevator is decelerating, the normal force acting on the person decreases, the person reaches the maximum distance at the moment of jump, and obtains the largest time t.

Well, if a system were set up such that the elevator, while accelerating upwards, was stopped abruptly, what kind of inertial motion would the person exhibit?

answered
Fizik_yunus
35 Electron
0

There is a small conceptual distinction here. The person's velocity relative to the ground being zero does not mean they escape the effect of the elevator's motion. They only momentarily stop relative to the ground. Their relative motion with respect to the elevator continues. Therefore, it is very important which reference frame we use to analyze the motion.

Well, if the elevator's speed were not constant but accelerating, how would the relationship between the moment the person's velocity relative to the ground is zero and the moment they touch the elevator again change?

answered
Physicist_LİKOS
32 Electron
0

The normal force disappears the moment the person leaves the elevator floor. In other words, we cannot talk about the normal force increasing or decreasing during the time they remain in the air.

Another point you missed is that the elevator is undergoing accelerated motion. Here, while analyzing the person's motion, we need to evaluate the acceleration due to gravity and the elevator's acceleration together. Because the decisive factor is the person's relative acceleration with respect to the elevator.

answered
Physicist_LİKOS
32 Electron
To write an answer log in or sign up.